Tue, May 22, 2012
The Faster Times
The Faster Times is an independent collective of journalists and writers who are looking to create a new model for the newspaper. Please support our work without spending a cent by signing up for email delivery and "liking" us on Facebook.
Email Delivery
SportsChat

Colt McCoy is no Faker, but is He the Real Deal?

colts face Colt McCoy is no Faker, but is He the Real Deal?

Colt McCoy

University of Texas football trainer Kenny Boyd confirmed what anybody with an above room temperature IQ already knew: Colt McCoy couldn’ t have gone back into the 2010 BCS National Championship game even if he wanted to.

“Colt sustained a nerve injury involving his right shoulder that prevented him from returning to the game. The injury caused numbness and weakness in his arm that prevented him from throwing with the strength or accuracy he needed,” Boyd said. “He wanted to go back into the game but with the weakness he was having in the shoulder, we couldn’t clear him to do that.

“The weakness in his shoulder also put him at risk of greater injury. From the time of the injury, we were continually treating and re-evaluating him, but he wasn’t able to regain the strength he needed to get back on the field.”

Nobody who has watched Colt become the winningest quarterback in college football history needed this clarification. Colt has all of the heart in the world.

But seeing him go down and separate his shoulder at the beginning of the championship game against the Alabama Crimson Tide does raise the issue of whether Colt will be able to take the kinds of hits on a daily basis necessary to make it as an NFL starter.

On paper, he seems a little small at 6-2 and 210 pounds. But barring a neck injury in his sophomore year, he was certainly displayed plenty of toughness at UT.

In so many ways, Colt McCoy’s career stands as a stark contrast to UT Longhorn legend Vince Young. When VY went pro, everybody knew he had the body to do be successful, but people questioned (unfairly in some ways, fairly in others) whether or not he had the head to make it at the next level. Nobody is asking that about Colt. It seems like Colt has a solid head on his shoulders, a dependable support group looking out for his best interests and just about all of the physical tools he needs to be a starter in the NFL.

Except for sheer size.

For every Drew Brees  (6-0), you can find a Peyton Manning (6-5), Matt Shaub (6-4), Phillip Rivers (6-5), and Vince Young (6-5) seeing over the top of the  monsters comprising the always growing defensive lines in the NFL.

Of course, Aaron Rodgers, Donovan McNabb, Brett Favre and Kurt Warner all top out at 6-2. And they aren’t half bad. But they each carry more weight than Colt.

Colt can expect to take hits like the one that took him out of the game against Alabama daily in practice in the NFL.

SportsChat is of the mind that he has the mobility to make up for his lack of height. But it looks like if he doesn’t bulk up by at least 15 pounds, he just might not have the sheer mass to take NFL hits. Ask Steve Slaton about adding on weight to make it in the NFL. It doesn’t always guarantee success. It can only hurt mobility. Nobody gains 20 pounds so they can be more spry.

What did y’all think of the hit that took Colt out? Did it mark him as vulnerable in the NFL? Or was it sufficiently vicious not to make you wonder? Do you think Colt has what it takes to be starter in the NFL? If so, how good do you think he will be?

share save 171 16 Colt McCoy is no Faker, but is He the Real Deal?
Share
655

MORE FROM Mason Lerner:

  1. Andy Pettitte Returns to the New York Yankees Vs Seattle Mariners
  2. MLB Picks (Easter) Sunday 4/8: Braves Mets & Yankees Rays Sweeps?
  3. MLB Picks Saturday 4/7: Tigers Red Sox, Yankees Rays, Rockies Astros
  • Lewis

    I don’t think he is good enough for the NFL. Flat out. He was up and down all year this year, and that won’t cut it in the NFL. He also won’t be able to scrambles as much in the NFL, and if he tries, he can count on guys like Ray Lewis making that hit against Alabama seem like a joke.

  • Dilberto

    You are the fake, Lerner! As you said, there are a lot of great NFL quarterbacks the same height as Colt. If you got hit as hard as he did in the BCS title game, you would never walk again. Colt is going to make some NFL GM look very, very smart.

  • GigEm

    I hope he liked watching the game in headphones and holding a clip board. Because that is all he will be able to do in the NFL. He has looked subpar every time UT lined up against a decent team this year.

  • http://www.inquisitr.com/56640/colt-mccoy-engaged/ Colt McCoy proposes to girlfriend Rachel Glandorf via scoreboard

    [...] injured his shoulder during the big-deal game against Alabama, and was unable to return to play: “Colt sustained a nerve injury involving his right shoulder that prevented him from returning to [...]

  • DirtySanchez

    Well he tore up the Aggies, GigEm, so I guess you know what that means. agreed that he will be a career back-up.

  • joshg

    Really? You guys actually think McCoy isn’t capable of making it in the NFL? Really? Y’all must not pay much attention to college football. Sure, he had a down season. Why? His coaches changed up their strategy with him this season because he and the rest of UT got screwed out of the title last year. Mack Brown had one goal this year: make it to the title game. If that meant holding back his beast of a qb, then so be it. McCoy will hold a clipboard for two or three years, then make all of the GMs who took a defensive end or tailback over him look like shortsighted fools.

    … and Sanchez: you seem like a classy guy, what with the shit-moustache-joke and all. Hope you don’t choke on your ring in that beer.

  • TexasTony

    I’m a Longhorn alum and even I can admit that McCoy doesn’t have what it takes to make it in the NFL. More than his physical stature, he lacks true toughness. In a coddling Mack Brown and a laid back Austin TX, a player gets to play football without the specter of an angry coach or a ruthless press. McCoy always has an excuse for his poor play. Those excuses won’t fly in the NFL.

Get our Newsletter