Mon, May 21, 2012
The Faster Times
The Faster Times is an independent collective of journalists and writers who are looking to create a new model for the newspaper. Please support our work without spending a cent by signing up for email delivery and "liking" us on Facebook.
Email Delivery
Diplomacy

Media Falling Down on Gitmo “Suicides”

I hope that anyone who has not already done so will read Scott Horton’s important piece in Harper’s investigating the cover-up of the 2006 deaths of three Guantanamo detainees, deaths which were publicly reported as suicides. (Or, in the Strangelovian language of the base’s commander, as acts of “asymmetrical warfare against us.”) Based on the testimony of several former Guantanamo military personnel, Horton provides strong evidence suggesting that the three detainees — none of whom had been charged with any crime — may in fact have been killed while being interrogated at a secret “black site” outside the main Guantanamo base.

It is not terribly surprising that the leading apologists for the Bush-Cheney torture regime — the likes of Marc Thiessen, Thomas Joscelyn, and so on — have refused to respond to Horton’s piece. What is more surprising, however, is that the major U.S. papers have paid little attention as well. After remaining silent all day, the New York Times and Washington Post finally posted an AP wire story on the revelations this evening, but it is nowhere to be found on their main pages. The Los Angeles Times still appears to have nothing whatsoever on the story.

By contrast, the major British papers (with the exception of Rupert Murdoch’s Times) have all followed up on Horton’s piece. It is by now a depressingly familiar pattern that the British media exhibit far more interest in the abuses of the Bush/Blair years than their American counterparts. Still, one would think that a possible triple homicide of detainees in U.S. custody, and the subsequent cover-up by both the Bush and Obama administrations, would merit some U.S. news coverage — even given the almost exclusive focus on Haiti and Massachusetts at the moment.

[Cross-posted at Lobelog.]

share save 171 16 Media Falling Down on Gitmo Suicides
Share


Daniel Luban lives in Chicago. He is a graduate student in political science at the University of Chicago, and also serves as a correspondent for the global news agency Inter Press Service, where his reporting focuses primarily on U.S. foreign policy and has been published ...

271

MORE FROM Daniel Luban:

  1. Too Early to Claim Vindication in Libya
  2. The Washington Post’s Jennifer Rubin Problem Worsens
  3. Former Intelligence Chief Calls for End to Drone War
  • Dado

    “Horton provides strong evidence suggesting that the three detainees — none of whom had been charged with any crime — may in fact have been killed while being interrogated at a secret “black site” outside the main Guantanamo base.”

    How about when “Horton” has evidence that these people were killed while being interrogated he gets back with us. BTW, my understanding of the Guantanamo base is that “outside” it, one would be Cuba. Where exactly would this mysterious “black site” be?

  • Daniel Luban

    I’d recommend you simply read the story for details. It provides a handy satellite map illustrating the apparent location of “Camp No” outside the perimeter of the main base. And although none of the Guantanamo personnel Horton interviews claim to have actually witnessed the detainees being killed, they provide strong circumstantial evidence suggesting that they were killed. To wit: the detainees were at Camp No, not in their cells as was publicly claimed, at the time of their deaths; the cause of death was widely reported within the base as having rags stuck down their throats, not hanging as was publicly claimed; a former top Guantanamo official was relieved of his post and suspended for even having mentioned the rags to reporters; the cloth masks that the detainees were apparently wearing dovetails with another detainee’s account of the abuse he sustained during interrogation; the three detainees’ throats were removed during the autopsy, thereby destroying any physical evidence that could indicate their cause of death; etc. Just read the story.

    I’m also slightly baffled why you put “Horton’s” name in scare quotes. Are you suggesting that he is not a real person? If you want I can probably get you some photographic evidence of his existence.

  • Nathan Alderman

    Mr. Luban, thank you for the link to Scott Horton’s article. This is an extremely disturbing subject that needs to be thoroughly examined in the public. President Obama wants to be the nice guy to the powers that perpetrated these crimes. It is the shameful attitude of “What can be gained by digging into the past? We should be looking into the future!”

    I believe as American citizens, we should be given full disclosure on how far the Neocons rammed our country into the absolute gutter of history.

  • Laurent

    Thanks for covering this. What is wrong with the mainstream media on this one? Pathetic, yes, but also difficult to understand. I suspect part of it is that the NYT and WaPo can’t stand that an “amateur” like Scott Horton (a career lawyer and fighter for justice, but not what the MSM would consider a journalist) brought such a crucial story to light. Maybe they are working on it, but if not, shame on them.

  • mooonorail

    In the New York Post story, Rupert Murdoch, who publishes the Post, made a statement that Claudia Naylor, the producer of a show that is under contract with MTV, slept with two men in the band. Untrue and libelous. Apparently Mr. Murdoch is confusing Claudia Naylor with his wife, who t\sleeps with everybody. She offers herself for the taking to men and women. She has totally broken up Murdoch’s family and is despised by Murdoch’s mother and many of his children. It is said that he hesitates to divorce her because it is alleged that she knows too much about his business dealings, some of which are suspect. Many people don’t know that a lovely couple brought Zenya from Shanghai to this country only to have Zenya seduce the husband and break up the marriage. Zenya wants it all. Once a slut, always a slut. As for the information which she has, if indeed he has committed a crime, he could always plead not guilty on the grounds of drunkenness.

    Fighters for Justice

Get our Newsletter